Today is Thursday, 23rd February 2012

After Simon Singh’s victory – what next?

The 15th of April was a good day for science and free speech, and skeptics will be relieved. Simon Singh took up the burden of fighting a libel suit brought against him when most others would have given up. No wonder: British libel laws can incur a cost far beyond other countries, and few would be willing to take the risk and have in the past given up. These laws have even led to libel tourism, with people from outside Britain carrying their cases to London in the hope of silencing critics of their doubtful claims.

However, the victory is only a first step. Simon Singh has said that “we need to maintain pressure” and pointed out that we need to support the ongoing campaign for Libel Reform in Britain. This is of central importance for the work of science journalists and popularizers of science from all over the world if we want to be able to speak openly and criticize dubious claims. ECSO has this added the Libel Reform Button to its web sites to underline our support for the campaign, which we call on all to support. With the elections coming up in the UK, now is the right time.

Euphrasia C5

Our two used-to-be-tomcats – Prankster Hrasko and Bubble Hrasko – had already surprised us several times with their health problems, so we were not very much afraid when we noticed on the younger that he had a pink eye. The nice veterinarian – who had already helped us several times – explained what the cause was, but the prescription and the treatment was a bit peculiar this time.

We had to buy a drug named Euphrasia C5. If someone did not know, he should suppose – based on the abbreviation C5 – that this must be a homeopathic remedy, in which the active ingredient is present in 1005 – i.e. ten billionth – dilution. That could even work, but based on the veterinarian C9 or C12 would be good as well. In the latest one the original tincture is diluted by 1024 and there are high chances that there is not a single molecule of the original substance present in the solvent. According to the homeopaths the solvent (water or alcohol) will “remember” the substance and it will express the proper effect within my cat.

Victory for Simon Singh

UPDATE (April 17, 2010): after reviewing the ruling, the BCA issued a notice of discontinuance. There will likely be a further court hearing to decide on how costs are to be awarded, but other than that the case is over. The seniority of the judges who heard the appeal means that the case sets a precedent for future libel cases concerning scientific criticism.


Top